One aspect of Race Based Law is the lack of property rights for reserve aboriginals. Legal equality would be a good way to begin to address the reserve housing issue:
“In its recent federal budget, the Liberal government committed $227 million in 2016/17 to “address urgent housing needs on reserve”, noting that ‘First Nations’ people living on reserve are “more likely to experience poor housing conditions and overcrowding than the general public”.
“In fact, according to recently released data from ‘Statistics Canada’, in every province the percentage of on-reserve ‘First Nations’ with homes in need of major repair is substantially higher, in some cases almost triple, the percentage of off-reserve ‘First Nations’ homes.
“More specifically, Alberta and Manitoba have the highest percentage of on-reserve homes in need of major repair with both provinces above 50%, compared to off-reserve ‘First Nation’ homes, at 14% and 21.9% respectively. Nationally, 42.9% of on-reserve ‘First Nation’ homes are in need of major repairs compared to only 15.4% of off-reserve ‘First Nation’ homes.
“So why the stark contrast between on- and off-reserve ‘First Nations’ housing? Is it only a lack of funding?
“Well, a potential contributing factor to the deplorable housing conditions on reserve may be a lack of property rights on reserve.
“Unfortunately, a ‘First Nations’ person on reserve does not enjoy fee simple ownership and does not have the same property rights as all other Canadians who live off reserve.
“According to the ‘Indian Act’, ‘First Nations’ reserve land is held in trust for on-reserve members by the federal government — essentially making on-reserve ‘First Nations’ people wards of the state. Because of this policy, ‘First Nations’ people who currently live on reserve are unable to earn equity on their home, use it as collateral to borrow money to undertake housing repairs, sell their land to whomever they choose, or bequest their land to their children.
“Further, research has shown that extending property rights to ‘First Nations’ reserve lands increases the quality of housing in a community. And extending full property rights on-reserve can promote economic growth. This research should not be overlooked by policymakers in Ottawa.
“Some ‘First Nations’ leaders wish to extend fee simple ownership to on-reserve residents. For example, Chief Michael LeBourdais of Whispering Pines ‘First Nation’ in B.C. believes property rights would help “restore [their] values and rights that the Indian Act took away” and make ‘First Nations’ partners in the market economy.
“In addition to funding, the government has committed to
“working with ‘First Nations’ communities over the coming year to develop an effective long-term approach to supporting . . . adequate supply of housing on reserve.”
“Hopefully, the engagement will include discussions with ‘First Nations’ leaders such as Chief LeBourdais and consideration to evidence-based research that outlines how extending property rights on reserve can improve the quality of housing in ‘First Nations’ communities.
“After all, as the ‘Statistics Canada’ numbers demonstrate, if it can be a factor in improving the quality of housing for off-reserve ‘First Nations’ people, perhaps it can do the same for on-reserve members.”
–‘Lack of Property Rights Root Cause of On-Reserve Housing Problems’,
Ravina Bains and Kayla Ishkanian, Troy Media/Battlefords News-Optimist, April 4, 2016 (Ravina Bains and Kayla Ishkanian are analysts at the Fraser Institute.)
END RACE BASED LAW CANADA (race laws)
ONE NATION ONE LAW CANADA (Facebook–broader politics)
1NATION1LAW (follow us)
Website – Daily News
ERBL inc. Canada News
Website – Featured Stories
END RACE BASED LAW inc. Canada
Petition to END RACE BASED LAW
mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org
JOIN US IN THE FUTURE OF A UNIFIED CANADA